First Love And Other Major Hemorrhoidal Issues
by
W.R. Marcy
We met in October of 1950 when we were sixteen; she was going on thirty five and in early menopause; I was going on twelve and in arrested development with a pompadour slicked up so high it had permafrost.
She was a pretty girl, maybe beautiful, but I was not ready to make such distinctions, or what beauty was apart from the eye of the beholder, or value the inner beauty of someone otherwise homely when it shines through to the surface.
She was a girl who was impossible to understand, who would create whirlwinds of confusion in me if I got too close, and by too close I mean emotionally, and by too close I mean in the same galaxy. A girl who drew me in over my head, a girl who, despite how much I thought I’d become to her or what I thought I would do for her, never let me know what she was thinking, or what she was feeling, or what went on in her world when I was in absentia.
A secretive girl who was at the one pulling me toward her and at the other pushing me away, a girl who had constructed an attractive castle in her emotional desert with high impenetrable walls to keep me and the storms of life outside without as much as a cup of comprehension to slake my thirst, a girl who would brush off a pointed question as if it had never been asked, or if pinned down, walk away without looking back. A girl who lived in a shell of something granite-like that made her needlessly hard, a girl who was a pain in the ass.
Was it a case of sexual incompatibility? We never had sex, so how would I know? The immutability of that logic notwithstanding, I had no doubt we were sexually incompatible from the beginning as I was the male, and thus I wanted to whether I did or not, and I didn’t; she was the female and she had to pretend she didn’t want to, and she didn’t. I think it was more a matter of us not having sex to avoid discovering we were sexually incompatible, as we had more than enough problems without that fire breathing dragon.
But for reasons I still do not understand she did not appeal to me sexually, nor apparently, I to her. How was that possible? What was the problem? She should have appealed to me, I wanted her to. She had lovely breasts, long shapely legs, a wonderful figure. And if she was not sexually attractive to me, then precisely what was it that drew me to her? At sixteen, the double yellow lines in the middle of the road or a parking meter could set me afire. And to give her her due, we even tried once near the end of whatever it was we were doing to one another, and my guess is that neither of us could put a name to that, but by then it had become too complicated, and too late, and anticlimactic of a sort.
Her indifference to everything . . . sex, me, the world, was of such a size it overwhelmed my libido. She lacked a joie de vivre, I lacked maturity, but for three years I kept returning to her, assuming each time I did I would find a changed, a less blasé, a more engaging person.
I read somewhere that sort of behavior is a symptom of insanity, that is, to keep doing the same painful thing in the same way over and over and expecting a different outcome every time.
Had we not done in today’s world what we did not do then, given the lushness of her, our age, and our glands, there would be talk of closets and repressed homosexuality, since in today’s narcissistic whorehouse of a world, if you have doubts about someone of any sort you simply Google them and the answers come pouring out, right answers, wrong answers, who cares? And if you don‘t like the answers then check the spelling or rephrase the question.
I was afraid, of what exactly I’m not sure, but at the time my being afraid was as natural as breathing, and besides, I had been for years warned of the consequences that went with . . . with what? Premarital sex and outraged fathers with shotguns? An infant in its crib completely dependent on me? That was closer to home. How could I take on the responsibility of a girl-woman and a child when I could not take care of myself.
Why did I keep returning to her? I suppose I had my own problems, but who doesn’t? Wouldn’t it be an equally legitimate question to ask, why did she continue, not so much to take me back, but not oppose my returning? What is it that the two of us wanted from each other? When we were in each other’s company we were scorpions in a bottle. I don’t remember a moment I spent searching for that which I wanted from her. Were the two of us going through the motions until the right one came along? But there must have been something that each of us had that the other wanted.
She went off to Rhode Island the summer she turned seventeen and got pregnant by a college boy. A healthy baby girl came the following spring. This was the early 50’s and it seemed only girls in cashmere sweaters, tartan plaid skirts, and bobby sox were getting into ‘trouble.’ I asked her to marry me. She thanked me, the only time I ever remember her generating a tender emotion with me, and turned me down. I didn’t love her, I’m not sure I even liked her that much, why would I, but I was inexplicably drawn to her. I wanted to protect her. Protect her from what, poverty? Had she said yes, had we married, poverty would have been our faithful companion to the end of our wretched days. Public censure? To protect her from the shame of foregoing the conventional administrative prelude before giving birth? Surprisingly, at least to me, she never seemed unduly bothered by the out of wedlock thing, the single motherhood life and all the freight that went with it at the time showed a great deal of tough-as-nails grit on her part, because even though the boy’s family arranged a light speed marriage to give the baby his name, then immediately started divorce proceedings, the matter had become common knowledge by way of gossips. Why did I want to marry her? To be gallant? At that time and at that age I set great store by things like chivalry, a code of honor to live by, and I wanted so to be a romantic; that was my mother coming out in me, and I should have known better. To show the world I was a man? That I had the same sort of courage that she had? I didn’t. I was not a man, and marriage wouldn’t make me so. It would take a long time and an extraordinary woman to make a man out of me. So what was that all about?
There was a destructive streak in my mother borne of the bleak and hopeless 1930’s depression and a source of problems for her, me, and everyone around her, the symptoms of which were dismissed out of hand at the time by the medical profession as female troubles. It is not love that makes the world go round, it is the bullshit of the medical profession that furnishes the necessary methane for the engine of rotation to maintain the spin.
I was cursed with a similar streak. To about the age of 43 I was discontent, going through the motions and hating it, wasting my life and my money, drinking too much, making destructive choices, waking up sick and ashamed and frightened because I knew I would be tossed whichever way the wind was blowing that day. Something was missing. I did not know what until I was in my 50’s. I avoided confronting my failings, but when I did, it was a pro forma sort of thing, and I got back to business as usual, destructive, stupid, warts and all. I mention this only because this was me from the start, and the package of problems I had would have been no solution for the girl’s problems.
Recently I read a piece where psychiatrists are beginning to retreat from their long held belief that there are no bad children, which is interesting as everyone but them seemed to know it, going back thousands of years. The article did not go into detail other than to state that some are born without conscience or compassion and are wired for the moment. I found that to be an unsatisfactory model in that it lumped everyone into one pot, the serial rapist child killer, with the selfish son of a bitch, or the passive aggressive bully, making no provision for degrees of badness, or at least did not imply that degrees of badness existed that I assume was an oversight in the article. I also mention this because maybe we, the girl and I were two people who were not bad people, but not good enough for one another. Go Figure. On second thought, all of this is tough enough to navigate without the “expert” input of the medical profession.
I knew when I was thirteen years old I had no future. I knew there were things I should be doing, preparing myself for matters the young must begin to deal with, but all of it was too much trouble and required too much from me. I ran from responsibility, I put no effort into anything, I had no self control, no discipline, I expected nothing but good luck all my life, and was only surprised when it did not happen. Later, the only real talent I had I was afraid to commit to because if I was wrong, if it turned out I did not have that talent, then there was nowhere I could hide from me or from those who took pleasure in mocking me for pretending to such talent. Regrettably, had I shown courage at nineteen or so with regard to what I wanted to do with my life, my life and the lives of those I loved would have been easier and more fulfilling. What’s the worst that could have happened if I committed? I find out I have no talent and I better get a job. Other than I would not have had the uncertainty regarding that talent on my back all my life, how is that different from the way things turned out?
Did I think that running into a marriage with someone who also had problems was the solution to my problems? Insane. I have come to suspect that the two of us did not know who we were. Why we weren’t introduced to ourselves was not a finger pointing fault, it was more a breach of good manners, a social faux pas that we, she and I committed . . . pardon my rudeness, but it appears I somehow forgot to introduce myself to me . . . am I to believe we were two people who couldn’t get to know one another because we didn’t know ourselves? That sounds crazy enough to be plausible. About the only thing good I could say of that period was that I learned what I was not looking for in a life’s partner, and I‘m only guessing, but I think the girl must have learned the same lesson, at least I hope she did. As it turned out, the thing I had going for me when I was young was an unbelievable lucky streak I ran in my early twenties. Her name was Linda.
The girl and my mother had both suffered wounds. Is that sufficient to explain anything? It doesn’t explain a thing, and it’s too New York Jewish intellectual for my liking and would mean I’d have to give up my Saturday softball game in the beer league to go to my house of worship, but it would have given me, if not an explanation, than at least a starting point at which to try to pull together the loose ends or the ends of me that did not fit.
The girl was attractive, my mother was beautiful. The girl was intelligent, my mother was talented. Both of them kept people at a distance. They both had an emotional wounds, my mother from the crushing weight of poverty by way of hard times, the girl, by way of her father’s walking out on his family when she was ten. Both women lived in a protective shell. Both women inflicted needless pain on themselves.
And then there is the incongruity of what precisely was my interest in the girl? It must have been platonic, because it wasn’t sexual, but if platonic then why all the adversity between us? Sexual tension? And knowing me, and at that age, how could it not have been sexual? I sometimes wonder if I wasn’t a surrogate for her father, daddy dumbest. Didn’t I have the same unattractive qualities as him, didn‘t I walk out on her regularly? What a mess that would be . . . . me looking for mommy, she looking for daddy. Maybe we could get a twofer with a shrink. I think a very good idea about now is to shrug my shoulders and walk away from it.
I do not know how much of this I should, or I want to explore. Over the past thirty years I have beaten up on myself in an ever increasing tempo over more important matters, matters far more on point. I have come to that bedraggled place in my thinking where there isn’t that much more to be gained by continuing to do so.
But there is the nagging something.
There is a great deal of parallelism between the girl and my mother, but, so what, and should I be surprised? Were I to find some great rift in me caused by either of these two women what would it explain and to what purpose? The problem I have with things like Oedipal explanations is that psychiatry is like constitutional law, we all know what the words mean, but it is the take on the words in total that is the difference. Do psychiatrists like the Supreme Court have the final say on those words, or are they suggesters of plausible explanations? No one has the final say.
I was always afraid. What I was afraid of I don’t know, but there was always something I feared from the time I was a boy. But don’t all kids live in fear of something?
Besides the things that kids are typically afraid of, I think I also feared rejection . . . discovery. I was afraid that my father, the greatest, strongest, most fearless, wisest, and kindest man on earth would find out, would come home from work one day at the bank keeping everyone cool in the summer and warm in the winter at exactly the same time he always did, and realize that I was not the son he wanted, he hoped for, wished for, could be proud of . . . And the Nobel prize for very difficult and impossibly complicated organic chemistry that only smart people who do not always disappoint their father have the smallest chance of knowing anything about goes to . . . No, not you, Billy, not in this lifetime and not in the next, and not until you learn the goddam multiplication tables.
Of course that’s dad taking the hit for failings that I had and admonishments I richly deserved, and besides, my father was a good man, a man who did his utmost for all of us, a man who, if he had problems made of hemlock would have swallowed them whole not inflict them on us.
My father loved the game of chess and was good at it, being rated a B or C level player by the ruling chess federation. He tried to teach me the game and succeeded only in teaching me how the individual pieces move. I had no patience in learning the openings, much less chess exotica, such as the end game. I do remember him telling me, “control the center of the board, castle early, and develop your pieces.” My father’s style of play was passive, one that allowed his opponent to beat himself. I would launch an attack on his position at the first opportunity that was furious and left nothing to the imagination, or in reserve, ignoring the fourth, the most important, and last thing I remember him telling me . . . “never underestimate the resources of the defender.”
I am sure it would not come as a surprise to anyone that I approached the girl as a game of chess with my father, but much like the game itself, I could not control the center of her board, nor was I smart enough to castle early to protect the king, which of course was me, and never got far enough into the game where I could develop my pieces, but most of all, I fully underestimated the resources of the defender.
I do not know what it is that is needed for people to overcome their problems, other than to grow up and live a life. How the grown up life is lived is the story, not what mom or dad did or didn‘t do, and the jury is still out on that.
I do know this, people can learn and people can change. That it is harder for some than for others goes without saying. But it is not a question of how hard it is, but whether or not we have deep down inside us what it takes to do it.
There is something though, something small and far from profound. My Linda, my wife, my love, was the only woman I ever knew who when she walked into a room I was in, I smiled and felt happy.
First Love? It was many things, not all of which were bad, but in time, a lot of time, I would come to know what love is, what friendship and caring and passion and holding someone dear is, and this was not it, none of it.
The end